|
TRAC
Daily Quote
 
"We may define "faith" as a firm belief in something for which there is not evidence ... Where there is evidence, no one speaks of "faith". We only speak of faith when we wish to substitute emotion for evidence."
- Bertrand Russell, 1955
 
       

Sponsors
 
Far Out Frags
 
       

Where Are They?
 
Members Where Are They?:
fragnut : Home
ghuffer : Forum
kazoh : Message Center
Visitor [5] : Home
Visitor [44] : Forum
youngtimothy : Forum
 
       

New Post(s) in Forum
 
» swapping at the december meeting
04 Dec, 16:06 » painterguy
» Honey Creek Outing - 11/30/08
04 Dec, 14:13 » schambers
» pacific east aquaculture group buy?
04 Dec, 14:11 » Briney Dave
» December Meeting Thread
04 Dec, 12:47 » MOsborne05
» lookin for a frag answer....
04 Dec, 12:13 » BuK
» Contest quality?
04 Dec, 11:36 » bixbe
» corals and few misc items for sale
04 Dec, 09:34 » BuK
» Finally started to cross over
04 Dec, 09:04 » Dune
» this is what happens when i get bored
04 Dec, 06:13 » Jimbo
» VHO setup
03 Dec, 21:17 » Neckelhead76
» Stocking a 30 gallon
03 Dec, 20:59 » Jimbo
» Baby Banggai
03 Dec, 20:12 » kazoh
» Nano Tanks on SALE @ Trilby Tropicals
03 Dec, 18:55 » OneThunder
» Tanks, equipment, fish for sale
03 Dec, 16:16 » Chad7531
» Corals Galore
03 Dec, 12:39 » BuK
» Whale Wars
03 Dec, 08:01 » Aquatic Aquaman
» Plastic Hose Clamps - Local Source?
02 Dec, 21:26 » hillbillyracin
» 300gal tank cracked today
02 Dec, 20:42 » bananaboat
» stauff forsale mag24......
02 Dec, 17:43 » bananaboat
» A new gift card promo - lasts untl Dec. 8th
02 Dec, 16:48 » ThatFishPlace
 
       

Toledo Reef Aquarium Club Forum
 
:: Home » Reef Keepers » A topic worth chewing on a bit: Low light corals
Author Messages
Briney Dave

Moderator
Posts : 1118
Location : N/A
Posted : 7/28/2008 9:35:36 PM  

This month's (July/August) issue of Coral Magazine has an interesting article on low light corals.  Not to be confused with what are commonly called beginer corals held by folks with lighting systems that will not support what they want resulting in weird colors/shapes and death.

these are corals that come from deeper  water (100+ feet)

The author argues for keeping such a tank for economic reasons but I think they make a very interesting second or in some folk's cases "other tank"

most of the colors tend to be dull browns or other off colors.   However, there will be some corals that respond to this environment by using some sort of floresences.  Not like pyrophyta (doing bio-lum) but capturing light and re-emitting it back onto the symbiotic algae layer.  The effect is the coral glowing in wierd colors.

There are a limited number of acros and other sps corals along with a limited number of soft corals.  The author suggests that some other corals that would naturally live in higher levels may be trained to thrive in the lower light.  He suggests starting those corals as frags rather than larger pieces already living in higher light levels.

I really do not have the time or space for another project this fall but something  to leave on the old back burner

I am interested to hear what others think of this

One of the biggest challenges that comes to my mind is figuring out the temperature for this sort of tank.  I think it could easily be 10 cooler than a traditional reef tank.  that might be hard to keep that cool????  I think there will be other parameter issues as well that may be a bit surprising (not in a good way)

Thoughts?????

your pal

Briney

Aquatic Aquaman

Moderator

Posts : 3591
Location : Ann Arbor, Mi
Posted : 7/29/2008 8:35:43 AM  

Briney Dave said :

This month's (July/August) issue of Coral Magazine has an interesting article on low light corals.  Not to be confused with what are commonly called beginer corals held by folks with lighting systems that will not support what they want resulting in weird colors/shapes and death.

these are corals that come from deeper  water (100+ feet)

The author argues for keeping such a tank for economic reasons but I think they make a very interesting second or in some folk's cases "other tank"

most of the colors tend to be dull browns or other off colors.   However, there will be some corals that respond to this environment by using some sort of floresences.  Not like pyrophyta (doing bio-lum) but capturing light and re-emitting it back onto the symbiotic algae layer.  The effect is the coral glowing in wierd colors.

There are a limited number of acros and other sps corals along with a limited number of soft corals.  The author suggests that some other corals that would naturally live in higher levels may be trained to thrive in the lower light.  He suggests starting those corals as frags rather than larger pieces already living in higher light levels.

I really do not have the time or space for another project this fall but something  to leave on the old back burner

I am interested to hear what others think of this

One of the biggest challenges that comes to my mind is figuring out the temperature for this sort of tank.  I think it could easily be 10 cooler than a traditional reef tank.  that might be hard to keep that cool????  I think there will be other parameter issues as well that may be a bit surprising (not in a good way)

Thoughts?????

your pal

Briney

I would really like to read that Article.  Funny thing is I subscribe to Coral Magazine and come to think of it I haven't had an Issue sent to me in a while...  I might have to look into that.

I would think that being lower light that you might want to increase the temperature rather then decrease.  The lower the Temperature the slower the growth rate and metabolism of the coral.  Unless you just want to maintain the coral and keep it from growing.

 

Toledo Reef Aquarium Club Web Administrator
KingDiamond


Posts : 218
Location : Toledo, Ohio
Posted : 7/29/2008 12:51:55 PM  
Briney Dave said :

This month's (July/August) issue of Coral Magazine has an interesting article on low light corals. Not to be confused with what are commonly called beginer corals held by folks with lighting systems that will not support what they want resulting in weird colors/shapes and death.

these are corals that come from deeper water (100+ feet)

The author argues for keeping such a tank for economic reasons but I think they make a very interesting second or in some folk's cases "other tank"

most of the colors tend to be dull browns or other off colors. However, there will be some corals that respond to this environment by using some sort of floresences. Not like pyrophyta (doing bio-lum) but capturing light and re-emitting it back onto the symbiotic algae layer. The effect is the coral glowing in wierd colors.

There are a limited number of acros and other sps corals along with a limited number of soft corals. The author suggests that some other corals that would naturally live in higher levels may be trained to thrive in the lower light. He suggests starting those corals as frags rather than larger pieces already living in higher light levels.

I really do not have the time or space for another project this fall but something to leave on the old back burner

I am interested to hear what others think of this

One of the biggest challenges that comes to my mind is figuring out the temperature for this sort of tank. I think it could easily be 10 cooler than a traditional reef tank. that might be hard to keep that cool???? I think there will be other parameter issues as well that may be a bit surprising (not in a good way)

Thoughts?????

your pal

Briney




Some lower light corals don't come from very deep water but have adapted to lower light levels because they grow slower getting shaded out by some of the faster growing species. I have kept frogspawn in very low light and it was fine. It just didn't reproduce as fast or grow as fast. Pavona cactus is another coral that comes to mind that can adapt to pretty low light levels.
"Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge: it is those who know little, not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved by science." - Charles Darwin
Briney Dave

Moderator
Posts : 1118
Location : N/A
Posted : 7/31/2008 8:55:19 PM  

Scott, I hope you find your missing issue(s)

Brad, that is very interesting.  In my 29 I am using a aqua-medic 250  M/H.  Despite the wattage it falls off on the sides of the tank rather dramatically.   I have a couple corals that had fallen to the sides and were sort of left there.  Their growth is much slower but they continue to grow. 

Most, although not all the corals discussed in the article were from deeper water.   The authors quoted some par values as definition of low light.  I will have to do a bit of reading to translate that into terms I can relate to more easily.  I know what photo active radiation means just not what the stated values would look like in a tank.  

Might be a really cool project to grow those out and keep some of the more shy fish which would do much better in the lower light

Aquatic Aquaman

Moderator

Posts : 3591
Location : Ann Arbor, Mi
Posted : 7/31/2008 9:38:15 PM  

Actually I just got my issue today...  It was beat up but I got it.

Toledo Reef Aquarium Club Web Administrator
Briney Dave

Moderator
Posts : 1118
Location : N/A
Posted : 8/5/2008 7:15:25 PM  

I still have not figured out why I have not subscribed to the magazine yet.

Aquatic Aquaman

Moderator

Posts : 3591
Location : Ann Arbor, Mi
Posted : 8/10/2008 11:59:24 AM  
Briney Dave said :

I still have not figured out why I have not subscribed to the magazine yet.


It's definetly worth it althought I think I'm missing an issue or two.

Toledo Reef Aquarium Club Web Administrator
« Previous   1 / 1   Next »
 
       

Copyright 2006 by Toledo Reef Aquarium Club Terms Of Use Privacy Statement